CastScience

Science Info and Calculations

Wind over water

Why the open lake is windier than the shore, and how the app gets the wind over the water that its wave and crossing rules use.

In plain words

Wind slows near the ground because the surface drags on it. Trees, buildings and fields are rough; open water is smooth. So at the standard measuring height of 10 m (33 ft) the wind over the open lake is usually stronger than at an airport on shore. The difference also depends on the air and water temperatures: when the lake is warmer than the air, as it often is in fall, the air over the water is heated from below, mixes, and brings faster wind from higher up down to the surface.

Waves, the crossing rule and water clarity all need the wind over the water, not the wind at the shore. The app therefore uses an over-water wind wherever one exists and scales a land wind up where it has to use one.

Where the over-water wind comes from

  1. The National Weather Service gridded forecast for a cell over open water (42.465 N, 82.754 W, mid-lake). It is already an over-water wind and is used as it is.
  2. If that cell has no forecast, the forecast for the shore point nearest your launch, multiplied by the land-to-water factor ff for the month (table below).
  3. For hours already past (water clarity looks back 48 hours): buoy 45147 in mid-lake when it reports, used as it is; otherwise the St. Clair Shores station (CLSM4) on the west shore, multiplied by its own factor fsf_s for the month and the direction its wind comes from (the station's section below); otherwise Selfridge Air National Guard Base (KMTC), multiplied by ff.
Land wind to over-water wind
Uwater=fm Uland,fm=factor of the calendar month at the lakeU_{\text{water}} = f_m \, U_{\text{land}}, \qquad f_m = \text{factor of the calendar month at the lake}

NWS marine products give wind in knots: 1 kt=1.15078 mph1\ \text{kt} = 1.15078\ \text{mph}. Directions are where the wind comes from, in degrees true; the app groups them into 8 sectors of 45 degrees, N being 337.5-22.5 degrees.

MonthJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
Factor f (Selfridge)1.191.191.191.171.040.950.981.101.271.371.411.54
Factor fsf_s (CLSM4), month only1.151.151.151.091.000.980.971.071.141.301.411.52

January to March have no buoy data (the buoy is out of the water in winter) and use the all-season factor (1.19 for Selfridge, 1.15 for CLSM4; by direction for CLSM4, below). The CLSM4 row is used only for a report without a direction. Before the calibration of 2026-10-02 the factor was 1.2 in every month, a Starting value: placeholder. The Shore Protection Manual (1984, chapter 3) gives the ratio of over-water to over-land wind for the Great Lakes as a curve that falls as the land wind rises (after Resio and Vincent, 1977); the buoy shows the same (below), so one factor per month is still a simplification.

Source: Lake record (data/seed/lakes.json); API: apps/api/src/lakestate.ts; engine: landToWaterFactorAt (overWater.ts), plan.ts.

Shore wind in October

Selfridge (KMTC) on the lake's west shore, Oct 3-15 of 2014-2025 (155 days with data): the daily mean wind was 8.2 mph, and on 50% of days it came from the SE, S or SW. Computed now from the seed table with the engine's sectors:

NNEESESSWWNW
10%11%7%17%17%16%14%9%

Days past the 7-day forecast use a daily wind of 8 mph for the water temperature projection, Starting value: close to this October mean (Water temperature).

Source: Iowa Environmental Mesonet daily summaries for KMTC (data/seed/weather_daily_selfridge.csv); trip analysis section 2.2.

How the factor was fitted

Calibration of 2026-10-02: buoy 45147 measures the wind in mid-lake and Selfridge measures it on land. Each hourly buoy record from 2000 to 2026 was paired with the Selfridge report nearest in time (at most 35 minutes apart). The buoy's anemometer is 5 m above the water, while forecasts and the wave model use wind at 10 m, so the buoy wind is raised by 1.0684, the ratio of the logarithmic wind profile over open water at 10 m and at 5 m. The factor is the mean over-water wind divided by the mean land wind, over the 22,102 hours with a land wind of 10 mph or more in 23 seasons: 1.19 for all seasons, with a 95% interval of 1.16-1.22 (bootstrap by year); single years scatter by 0.09. Seasons when a sensor failed or read low are left out.

The ratio depends mostly on the air and water temperatures. With the water 7 F or more warmer than the air it is 1.58; with the air 3.6-7 F warmer than the water it is 0.93. The lake is warmer than the air in fall and colder in early summer, so the monthly factor runs from 0.95 in Jun to 1.54 in Dec. It also falls with the land wind: 1.48 at 5-10 mph, 1.13 at 15-20 mph. By the direction the wind comes from, it is lowest from the southeast (0.93), when the wind has crossed the lake before it reaches Selfridge.

Why it matters

Wave height grows faster than wind speed. In October a 15 mph land wind is 20.6 mph over water with the fitted f=1.37f = 1.37, where the old f=1.2f = 1.2 gave 18.0 mph; over 30 km of fetch at 4 m depth the modeled HsH_s is 2.15 ft instead of 1.90 ft, 13% higher. Measured over-water wind predicted from land wind of 10 mph or more: root-mean-square error 5.5 mph with the monthly factors, 6.0 mph with 1.2; in October the old factor ran 2.2 mph low on average. See the wave disclaimer and Validation.

Source: reports/calibration-1.8-20261002.md; reports/calibration-latest.json (scripts/calibration/wind.ts).

The St. Clair Shores station

Station CLSM4 (National Weather Service, through the National Data Buoy Center) stands on the west shore at 42.471 N, 82.877 W, with its anemometer 10 m above the site, and reports every 10 minutes all year. The app stores its report on the hour. Its factor was fitted the same way against buoy 45147: 20,120 hours with a station wind of 10 mph or more in 20 seasons, 1.15 for all seasons (95% interval 1.12-1.17), by month 0.97 in Jul to 1.52 in Dec.

Standing at the water's edge, the station reads nearly the lake wind when the lake is upwind and much less when the wind has crossed land: all seasons, from the east 1.01, from the west 1.24, from the northwest 1.58. So the app uses its factor by month and by direction (one of 8 sectors, table): a month and direction with 100 hours or more of data has its own factor; the others keep the month factor (in brackets); January to March, without buoy data, take the all-season factor of the direction. With 100 hours or more, a factor's 95% interval is at most +/-0.14; fewer hours come from a few seasons and can reflect one or two storms. This departs from the one-factor-per-month method above (decided 2026-10-03).

MonthNNEESESSWWNW
Jan1.101.001.010.941.341.321.241.59
Feb1.101.001.010.941.341.321.241.59
Mar1.101.001.010.941.341.321.241.59
Apr(1.09)(1.09)1.11(1.09)(1.09)1.14(1.09)(1.09)
May1.000.961.030.931.090.970.99(1.00)
Jun1.010.910.930.901.161.020.961.23
Jul1.050.960.830.771.111.060.91(0.97)
Aug1.111.000.980.851.271.251.11(1.07)
Sep1.151.031.040.991.411.311.281.74
Oct1.211.061.061.061.481.471.481.77
Nov1.241.071.081.111.491.611.501.79
Dec(1.52)(1.52)(1.52)(1.52)(1.52)1.711.61(1.52)

On the hours both stations and the buoy reported, the over-water wind it predicts was off by 4.7 mph (root-mean-square; 5.2 mph by month alone) against 5.6 mph from Selfridge, so it comes before Selfridge. Waves estimated from it: actual waves were 25% or more higher in 41% of the hours with waves of 1 ft or more (45% by month alone, 45% from Selfridge).

Source: reports/stclair-feeds-20261003.md; reports/calibration-latest.json (scripts/calibration/shore.ts); lake record shore_stations.

Constants

ConstantValueIn the codeBasis
Land-to-water wind factor by month0.95-1.54land_to_water_factor_monthly (lake record)Fit, buoy 45147 against KMTC 2000-2026 (2026-10-02)
Land-to-water wind factor, all seasons1.19land_to_water_factor (lake record)Same fit; January to March, without buoy data
St. Clair Shores (CLSM4) factor by month0.97-1.52shore_stations[].to_water_factor_monthly (lake record)Fit, buoy 45147 against CLSM4, 2007-2026
St. Clair Shores (CLSM4) factor, all seasons1.15shore_stations[].to_water_factor (lake record)Same fit; a report without a direction
St. Clair Shores (CLSM4) factor by month and direction0.77-1.79shore_stations[].to_water_factor_by_month_sector (lake record)Same fit by month and sector; 100 hours or more for a sector of its own, else the month factor (2026-10-03)
Knots to mph1.15078MPH_PER_KT (units.ts)1 kt = 1852 m per hour, 1 mi = 1609.344 m; rounded to 5 decimals
Daily wind past the forecast8 mphengine.default_day_wind_mph (lake record)Starting value: near the October mean at Selfridge
Wind sectors8 of 45 degSECTORS, sectorOf (geo.ts)Compass points

Sources

  • National Weather Service API, gridded forecasts; NWS marine forecast for zone LCZ460.
  • Buoy 45147 (Lake St. Clair): Environment and Climate Change Canada; history from Fisheries and Oceans Canada (Marine Environmental Data Section) via CIOOS Pacific. Contains information licensed under the Open Government Licence - Canada. Real-time data: NOAA National Data Buoy Center.
  • Iowa Environmental Mesonet, daily and hourly airport observations (KMTC, KDTW).
  • St. Clair Shores station CLSM4: NOAA National Weather Service and National Data Buoy Center (real-time reports; yearly history files 2007-2025 for the fit).
  • U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (1984), Shore Protection Manual, chapter 3; Resio and Vincent (1977), Estimation of winds over the Great Lakes.
  • Links: References.