CastScience

Guides

Buffalo and the head of the Niagara River: smallmouth on the shoals

At its east end Lake Erie narrows toward Buffalo, New York, and flows into the Niagara River. The app has 6 smallmouth bass areas within 12.7 mi of Buffalo Harbor State Park boat launch: 4 in New York water and 2 in Ontario water. This page gives each area's depth and bottom as the app records them, the tournaments held from Buffalo and the reports that name these shoals, the season, waves by wind direction, the boat ride from each launch, and the New York, Ontario and border rules, each with its source.

The shoals

Not for navigation. Use official charts and your chartplotter.

AreaWaterDepth in the planBottom, as the app records it
Buffalo Harbor outer breakwalls (lake side, Buffalo Harbor Light to the South Entrance)New York10-30 ftRubble-mound breakwalls; rock (GLAHF)
Smoke Creek Shoals off Woodlawn Beach State ParkNew York8-20 ftSand, gravel and rubble under 20 ft (NY DOS, Smoke Creek Shoals); rock and sand/gravel (GLAHF)
Waverly Shoal and Roses Reef (Fort Erie, Canadian side of the Niagara River head)Ontario10-25 ftShoal, least depth 10 ft (Coast Pilot); rock (GLAHF)
Seneca ShoalNew York12-30 ftRocky ridge of about 400 acres (NY DOS); rock and sand/gravel (GLAHF)
Myers Reef (off Hamburg)New York18-40 ftSpur of 30-44 ft on the corrected depth grid; sand/gravel (GLAHF)
Point Abino and Abino BayOntario10-30 ftrock (GLAHF)

Approximate centres, not waypoints: Buffalo Harbor outer breakwalls 42.862 N, 78.896 W; Smoke Creek Shoals off Woodlawn Beach State Park 42.805 N, 78.870 W; Waverly Shoal and Roses Reef 42.867 N, 78.953 W; Seneca Shoal 42.789 N, 78.929 W; Myers Reef 42.748 N, 78.970 W; Point Abino and Abino Bay 42.827 N, 79.100 W.

Caution the plan shows on Waverly Shoal and Roses Reef: In the Fort Erie sanctuary (Stonemill Road to Rosehill Road): all fishing is closed from June 1 to July 15 (Ontario Fishing Regulations Summary, FMZ 19).

Tournaments held from Buffalo

EventDatesWinner and weightLake water, basin meanDepth of waterBaits
EverStart Series Northern DivisionAug 25 to Aug 28, 2004Joseph Pappas, 39.81 lb in 2 days69.7 F30-44 ftTube; drop shot
Bassmaster Elite Series Empire ChaseJuly 19 to July 22, 2007Edwin Evers, 65.44 lb in 3 days70.4 F36-42 ftDrop shot (Yum Houdini worm)
Bassmaster Elite Series Empire ChaseJuly 31 to Aug 3, 2008Kotaro Kiriyama, 93.38 lb in 4 days74.6 F30-90 ftDrop shot (Jackall Crazy Ninja worm)
EverStart Series Northern DivisionAug 18 to Aug 20, 2011Lawrence Mazur, 64.50 lb in 3 days76.0 F40-75 ftDrop shot (Poor Boys Erie Darter, goby colors)
National Guard FLW College Fishing Northern DivisionAug 20, 2011N.C. State University (Johnson, Hooks), 20.25 lb76.2 Fnot statedDrop shot (Jackall Cross Tail Shad)
Costa FLW Series Northern DivisionJuly 26 to July 28, 2018Neil Farlow, 24.25 lb73.9 F20-40 ftDrop shot (Reaction Innovations Flirt Worm)
Turtlebox Bassmaster Open at Lake Erie (Division 1)Aug 20 to Aug 22, 2026Alex Korol, 75.56 lb in 3 days75.4 F48-52 ftDrop shot (Megabass Hazedong Shad)

Where the winner fished, as reported:

  • EverStart Series Northern Division, 2004: An area that was not obvious, chunk rock and sand, after a 15-mi run; bigger fish at 38-44 ft; place not named.
  • Bassmaster Elite Series Empire Chase, 2007: Three of 17-18 waypoints, offshore; a single rock with schools of smallmouth around it; place not named.
  • Bassmaster Elite Series Empire Chase, 2008: Two spots near the Pennsylvania border, almost 70 mi from Buffalo; suspended fish under baitfish schools over deep water.
  • EverStart Series Northern Division, 2011: A deep shelf of chunk rock and boulders off Angola, N.Y.; day 2 rocks at 40-48 ft "south around Angola", day 3 about a quarter mile from the day-2 fish at 52-75 ft.
  • National Guard FLW College Fishing Northern Division, 2011: A series of humps off the main channel, drifted with a drift sock; place not named.
  • Costa FLW Series Northern Division, 2018: Six areas from Point Abino (Ontario) to Myers Reef (N.Y.) and back toward Buffalo; four produced the big fish (the app's records link it to Point Abino and Abino Bay; Myers Reef; Smoke Creek Shoals off Woodlawn Beach State Park; Seneca Shoal; Buffalo Harbor outer breakwalls).
  • Turtlebox Bassmaster Open at Lake Erie (Division 1), 2026: A half-mile stretch without obvious structure but with bait schools, close to well-known contours; place not named.

The app's tournament records with the takeoff at Buffalo; the records link 1 of the 7 to these areas. Lake water: NOAA's Great Lakes Surface Environmental Analysis (GLSEA), the eastern basin's mean over the event dates. Weights in lb to 0.01 lb as the records hold them.

Reports and research that name these shoals

  • April 17, 2007: Before the 2007 Empire Chase, the event preview named Eighteen Mile Creek, Seneca Shoal and the rocks along Buffalo Harbor as known smallmouth spots, and Waverly Shoal, farther out, as a series of current-washed rocky humps. Tubes were the most used bait, then jigs, spinnerbaits and jerkbaits. Source: Lake Erie/Niagara River (Bassmaster preview of the 2007 Empire Chase). Areas: Buffalo Harbor outer breakwalls; Seneca Shoal; Myers Reef; Waverly Shoal and Roses Reef.
  • Aug 13, 2008: Mike Iaconelli (day-2 leader with 44 lb 5 oz; 4th after day 3 with 62 lb 1 oz) caught all his fish on a drop shot at places within 5 mi of the Buffalo weigh-in site, while the leaders ran 45-70 mi. No spot named. Source: Closing in on a win (Iaconelli, day-2 leader, 2008 Empire Chase). Areas: Buffalo Harbor outer breakwalls; Seneca Shoal; Smoke Creek Shoals off Woodlawn Beach State Park; Waverly Shoal and Roses Reef.
  • Aug 4, 2011: Before the 2011 event, Dave Lefebre said long runs toward Pennsylvania, Dunkirk or Barcelona have won many tournaments, Canadian water usually puts one or two anglers in the top 10, and humps at the mouth of the Niagara River are a fall-back. He expected bass suspended at 20-60 ft and named drop shots with small worms and goby imitations. Source: EverStart Northern Division to host event on Lake Erie (Lefebre preview). Areas: Waverly Shoal and Roses Reef.
  • July 18, 2018: Before the 2018 event, Chris Johnston expected about half the field on each side of the border, with the most boats from Buffalo out to the Myers Reef area and across, and the bigger fish at 20-45 ft, on tubes dragged on drifts, then on drop shots. Source: Lake Erie set for Costa FLW Series Northern Division event (Johnston preview). Areas: Buffalo Harbor outer breakwalls; Seneca Shoal; Smoke Creek Shoals off Woodlawn Beach State Park; Myers Reef.
  • July 27, 2018: Ben Wright (2nd, 24 lb 3 oz in the one-day event) dragged a drop shot around the Waverly Shoal area, a rocky shoal where the bottom changes from gravel to chunk rock, with a breakline at 31-39 ft. The bite was strongest early and slower by midday. Source: Top 5 Patterns from Lake Erie Day 1 (Wright, 2nd). Areas: Waverly Shoal and Roses Reef.
  • Seneca Shoal, a shoal with a least depth of 12 ft about 4.4 mi south-west of Stony Point, marked on its north-west edge by a lighted buoy; the only shoal far offshore on the south shore. Source: NOAA U.S. Coast Pilot 6, chapter 6 (Lake Erie), edition of 27 Sep 2026, paragraphs 196-197. Areas: Seneca Shoal.
  • Waverly Shoal, a shoal with a least depth of 10 ft, 1.9 mi west-southwest of Buffalo Harbor Light; numerous unmarked detached shoal spots under 30 ft in the approaches to Buffalo Harbor and the Niagara River at the east end of the lake. Source: NOAA U.S. Coast Pilot 6, chapter 6 (Lake Erie), edition of 27 Sep 2026, paragraph 150. Areas: Waverly Shoal and Roses Reef; Buffalo Harbor outer breakwalls.
  • Rocky underwater ridge of about 400 acres about 3 mi west of Hamburg; 12-30 ft over the shoals, up to 50 ft around; believed to be a major spawning area for smallmouth bass, walleye, yellow perch and rock bass; one of the most popular fishing areas in New York Lake Erie water. Source: NY Department of State, Significant Coastal Fish and Wildlife Habitat: Seneca Shoals (rating form, 1987). Areas: Seneca Shoal.
  • About 500 acres within 0.5 mi of the Smoke Creek mouth (Lackawanna-Hamburg line), mostly under 20 ft, sand, gravel and rubble; probably an important spawning area for walleye, yellow perch and smallmouth bass. Source: NY Department of State, Significant Coastal Fish and Wildlife Habitat: Smoke Creek Shoals (rating form, 1987). Areas: Smoke Creek Shoals off Woodlawn Beach State Park.
  • Smallmouth spawning or nursery records near these areas: Fort Erie, Abino Bay and Eighteenmile Creek, among the eastern basin's sites. Source: GLAHF fish spawning and nursery sites (after Goodyear et al. 1982), smallmouth bass records in the eastern basin. Areas: Myers Reef; Waverly Shoal and Roses Reef; Point Abino and Abino Bay.
  • Eight New York sites near the launches: Seneca Shoal (12 ft, water to 30 ft around it, bedrock common; state sampling found abundant 1-4 lb bass in the deeper water toward Athol Springs), Sturgeon Point east (bedrock) and west (reefs 1.5 and 3 mi south-west of the breakwall, 12-30 ft), Cattaraugus Creek, Dunkirk Harbor (the power plant discharge draws forage and bass; bedrock at Battery Point), reef-type structures about 1 mi north-east of Van Buren Point and peaks and valleys in 20-45 ft west of it, and Barcelona east and west (rock bottom). Bass move to shoals of 10-45 ft in early summer and are most concentrated there from late July through September. Source: New York Sea Grant: Angling for Smallmouth Bass in Lake Erie (M. Malchoff, 1984, NYEXT-H-84-001). Areas: Seneca Shoal.

Tournament previews and reports, agency habitat forms and charts in the app's evidence table for these areas. Previews are not catch reports. Depths are of water on the day, as the authors give them.

CastScience does not endorse fishing in spawning areas during the spawning season. The spawning sites are shown so that they can be avoided.

The season at the Buffalo end

MonthLake temperature, basin mean: median (10th-90th percentile)Most common phase and its target depthTournaments held from Buffalo
May47.7 F (41.9-55.5 F)Pre-spawn 65%: 15-35 ftnone
June62.9 F (56.0-68.6 F)Spawn 61%: 6-20 ftnone
July72.2 F (68.4-75.8 F)Summer 80%: 20-45 ftJuly 19, 2007; July 31, 2008; July 26, 2018
August74.2 F (71.6-76.8 F)Summer 100%: 20-45 ftAug 25, 2004; Aug 18, 2011; Aug 20, 2011; Aug 20, 2026
September70.2 F (66.6-73.7 F)Summer 78%: 20-45 ftnone
October61.0 F (56.0-66.6 F)Early fall 70%: 20-45 ftnone
November51.3 F (47.3-55.4 F)Late fall 97%: 35-60 ftnone

Daily GLSEA basin means, 1995-2025; the plan scores these areas on the basin mean. The phase share counts the days on which the eastern basin's rules give that phase: see Lake Erie eastern basin smallmouth by month.

Dates in 2027Bass in New York waterBass in Ontario water
Jan 1 to June 14Open: keep 1 a day, 20 in or longerClosed
June 15 to June 25Open: keep 5 a day, 12 in or longerClosed
June 26 to Nov 30Open: keep 5 a day, 12 in or longerOpen: keep 6 a day on a sport licence or 2 a day on a conservation licence
Dec 1 to Dec 31Open: keep 1 a day, 20 in or longerClosed

In Ontario water bass may not be fished at all outside the season (2027: June 26 to Nov 30), catch and release included. In New York water bass may be fished all year, with the limits of the dates above.

Dates in 2027 computed from the rule as of 2026-10-04. Sources: NYSDEC: Great Lakes and Tributaries Special Regulations, Lake Erie seasons and limits; 6 NYCRR 10.2(a), Table A (last amended effective 2023-11-13); Ontario Fishing Regulations Summary 2026: Fisheries Management Zone 19.

Wind and waves

The CastScience Wave Prediction at each area's centre: the significant wave height (Hs, the average of the highest third of the waves) and the largest wave in about an hour, in a 15 mph wind over the water.

Wind fromBuffalo Harbor outer breakwallsSmoke Creek Shoals off Woodlawn Beach State ParkWaverly Shoal and Roses ReefSeneca ShoalMyers ReefPoint Abino and Abino Bay
N0.9 ft / 1.7 ft1.6 ft / 3.0 ft0.8 ft / 1.4 ft1.7 ft / 3.2 ft2.0 ft / 3.7 ft1.3 ft / 2.4 ft
NE0.7 ft / 1.3 ft0.9 ft / 1.7 ft1.0 ft / 1.9 ft1.3 ft / 2.4 ft1.5 ft / 2.8 ft1.6 ft / 3.0 ft
E0.9 ft / 1.6 ft0.6 ft / 1.1 ft1.3 ft / 2.4 ft1.1 ft / 2.1 ft1.4 ft / 2.6 ft1.7 ft / 3.1 ft
SE1.5 ft / 2.8 ft0.9 ft / 1.7 ft1.8 ft / 3.4 ft1.1 ft / 2.0 ft1.0 ft / 1.9 ft2.1 ft / 3.9 ft
S3.4 ft / 6.3 ft3.3 ft / 6.1 ft3.3 ft / 6.2 ft3.3 ft / 6.2 ft3.4 ft / 6.3 ft3.6 ft / 6.6 ft
SW3.5 ft / 6.5 ft3.6 ft / 6.6 ft3.4 ft / 6.3 ft3.6 ft / 6.7 ft3.7 ft / 6.9 ft3.6 ft / 6.8 ft
W3.5 ft / 6.5 ft3.6 ft / 6.7 ft3.4 ft / 6.4 ft3.6 ft / 6.7 ft3.7 ft / 6.9 ft3.6 ft / 6.8 ft
NW3.1 ft / 5.8 ft3.5 ft / 6.5 ft3.0 ft / 5.6 ft3.5 ft / 6.6 ft3.6 ft / 6.7 ft3.3 ft / 6.2 ft

Each cell: Hs / largest wave in about an hour at 15 mph. Above 2.0 ft: caution. Depths below LWD; with the lake 1 m above it no height here is more than 0.1 ft higher.

The fetch is longest with wind from SW and W: 85.7-107.0 km (53.3-66.5 mi) at these areas. With the slanting fetch, wind up to 45 deg off those directions raises waves on that fetch too. At 20 mph Hs stays at 2.0 ft or less only with wind from these directions: Buffalo Harbor outer breakwalls, N, NE, E; Smoke Creek Shoals off Woodlawn Beach State Park, NE, E, SE; Waverly Shoal and Roses Reef, N, NE, E; Seneca Shoal, NE, E, SE; Myers Reef, E, SE; Point Abino and Abino Bay, N.

Wave heights are model estimates from forecast wind, not measurements, with a 1.10 safety factor. Actual waves were higher than the estimate in about 1 hour in 13 offshore and 1 in 45 near shore. Check the marine forecast and the water at the launch; the decision to go out is yours. Full text

Boat ride from each launch

LaunchBuffalo Harbor outer breakwallsSmoke Creek Shoals off Woodlawn Beach State ParkWaverly Shoal and Roses ReefSeneca ShoalMyers ReefPoint Abino and Abino Bay
Erie Basin Marina boat launch (New York)1.4 mi (2.3 km); 3 min and 5 min5.5 mi (8.9 km); 12 min and 18 min3.5 mi (5.6 km); 7 min and 12 min6.7 mi (10.8 km); 14 min and 22 min10.1 mi (16.3 km); 22 min and 34 min11.4 mi (18.3 km); 24 min and 38 min
Buffalo Harbor State Park boat launch (New York)2.1 mi (3.3 km); 4 min and 7 min4.0 mi (6.5 km); 9 min and 13 min5.0 mi (8.0 km); 11 min and 17 min6.2 mi (9.9 km); 13 min and 21 min9.7 mi (15.6 km); 21 min and 32 min12.7 mi (20.4 km); 27 min and 42 min
Sturgeon Point Marina (New York)14.0 mi (22.6 km); 30 min and 47 min11.9 mi (19.2 km); 26 min and 40 min13.0 mi (21.0 km); 28 min and 43 min9.0 mi (14.5 km); 19 min and 30 min5.5 mi (8.9 km); 12 min and 18 min9.8 mi (15.8 km); 21 min and 33 min
Sugarloaf Marina public boat ramp, Port Colborne (Ontario)19.4 mi (31.3 km); 42 min and 65 min20.7 mi (33.3 km); 44 min and 69 min16.7 mi (26.9 km); 36 min and 56 min18.0 mi (29.0 km); 39 min and 60 min17.3 mi (27.9 km); 37 min and 58 min9.0 mi (14.4 km); 19 min and 30 min
Sunset Bay State Marine Park (New York)24.0 mi (38.6 km); 51 min and 80 min21.9 mi (35.3 km); 47 min and 73 min22.9 mi (36.8 km); 49 min and 76 min19.0 mi (30.5 km); 41 min and 63 min15.5 mi (24.9 km); 33 min and 52 min18.1 mi (29.2 km); 39 min and 61 min
Boat ride:
Distance along a path over water from the launch to the area, avoiding water charted under 2 ft. It measures the distance; it is not a course to steer.
Times:
The distance along a path over water at the plan's default boat speeds, 28 mph in calm water and 18 mph in chop; set your own in Setup.

The table lists the launches with a boat ride of 25 mi or less to every area of this page. The boat rides from the New York launches to Waverly Shoal and Roses Reef and to Point Abino and Abino Bay, and from Sugarloaf Marina public boat ramp, Port Colborne to the New York areas, cross the U.S.-Canada boundary: fishing in Ontario water needs an Ontario licence, and the border rules below say when a report is needed.

From Buffalo Harbor State Park boat launch toHighest Hs on the boat ride at 15 mph, lowest to highest wind directionThe same at 20 mph
Buffalo Harbor outer breakwalls0.7 ft (NE) to 3.6 ft (W)1.0 ft (NE) to 5.3 ft (W)
Smoke Creek Shoals off Woodlawn Beach State Park0.6 ft (E) to 3.6 ft (W)0.8 ft (E) to 5.3 ft (W)
Waverly Shoal and Roses Reef1.0 ft (N) to 3.6 ft (W)1.4 ft (N) to 5.3 ft (W)
Seneca Shoal1.1 ft (E) to 3.6 ft (W)1.6 ft (E) to 5.4 ft (W)
Myers Reef1.2 ft (SE) to 3.7 ft (W)1.7 ft (SE) to 5.5 ft (W)
Point Abino and Abino Bay1.2 ft (N) to 3.6 ft (SW)1.7 ft (N) to 5.4 ft (W)

The highest Hs along the path over water from the launch to the area, as the plan computes it for each hour.

Rules in New York water, Ontario water and at the border

Summary only. Check the official regulations before fishing.

New York water

  • Anglers 16 years or older need a New York fishing licence; an annual licence is valid 365 days from the date of purchase. NYSDEC: Fishing Licenses (license requirements), as of 2026-10-04.
  • Fees: non-resident annual $50, 7-day $28, 1-day $10; resident annual $25 (ages 16-69) or $5 (70 and older), 7-day $12, 1-day $5. NYSDEC: Fishing Licenses (types and fees), as of 2026-10-04.
  • A New York licence is not valid in the Pennsylvania or Ontario parts of Lake Erie, nor in the Ontario part of the Niagara River. NYSDEC: Fishing Licenses (license requirements for border waters), as of 2026-10-04.
  • Each angler may operate no more than 3 lines, with or without a rod, each with no more than 5 lures or baits and no more than 15 hook points, and must be in immediate attendance while lines are in the water. NYSDEC: General Freshwater Fishing Regulations (Methods of taking fish: angling), as of 2026-10-04.
  • You may keep fishing after reaching the daily limit if every further fish of that species is released at once; a single uninjured largemouth or smallmouth bass being landed, measured or released from a recirculating or aerated livewell does not count toward the daily limit. NYSDEC: General Freshwater Fishing Regulations (Possession and daily limits), as of 2026-10-04.
  • Round goby may not be used as bait; uncertified baitfish, including baitfish you collect yourself, may be used only in the water where they were collected (Lake Erie, the Upper Niagara River and the Black Rock Canal count as one water) and moved by vehicle only inside the Lake Erie-Upper Niagara River corridor; certified baitfish need a seller receipt no older than 10 days. NYSDEC: Baitfish Regulations, as of 2026-10-04.

Niagara River north of the Peace Bridge (New York water)

Ontario water (Fisheries Management Zone 19)

Entering Canadian water: Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA)

Returning to U.S. water: U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP)

  • A U.S. boat that enters Canadian waters and returns without touching Canadian soil, without contact with a foreign vessel and without receiving goods does not report to CBP; otherwise the operator must report the arrival to CBP immediately on landing. CBP: Pleasure Boat Reporting Requirements, as of 2026-10-04.
  • Report a U.S. arrival from Canada with the free CBP ROAM app, on your own device or on CBP tablets at local businesses that include Smith Boys at Erie Basin Marina and Chadwick Bay Marina; NEXUS, I-68 or Verified Traveler holders may instead call 1-800-827-2851; the page lists no in-person marine reporting location on Lake Erie (its listed ports are on the St. Lawrence River). CBP: Northern New York State pleasure boat reporting locations, as of 2026-10-04.
  • Failing to report to CBP can bring a civil penalty of USD 5,000 for a first violation and USD 10,000 for each later one, and the boat can be seized and forfeited. CBP: Pleasure Boat Reporting Rules for Michigan Waterways with Canada (local media release), as of 2026-10-04.

See Regulations, Lake Erie (eastern basin) for every rule of the lake with its source, and Bass season dates 2027 for the Pennsylvania water.

Sources and related pages

  • Areas, depths, bottoms and positions: the app's area records of Lake Erie (eastern basin), with the sources named on each area's page.
  • Tournaments, reports and research: the source linked on each row, as the app's records hold them.
  • Lake temperature: NOAA Great Lakes Environmental Research Laboratory (GLERL), GLSEA, the eastern basin mean, 1995-2025. Waves: the Shore Protection Manual (1984) method on each area's fetch and depth tables, as the area pages and the plan use it.
  • Abbreviations: B.A.S.S., Bass Anglers Sportsman Society; CAD, Canadian dollars; CBP, U.S. Customs and Border Protection; CBSA, Canada Border Services Agency; FLW, Fishing League Worldwide; FMZ, Fisheries Management Zone; GLAHF, Great Lakes Aquatic Habitat Framework; GLERL, Great Lakes Environmental Research Laboratory; GLSEA, Great Lakes Surface Environmental Analysis; HST, harmonized sales tax; Hs, significant wave height; LWD, low water datum; MLF, Major League Fishing; NOAA, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration; NY DOS, New York Department of State; NYCRR, New York Codes, Rules and Regulations; NYSDEC, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation; USD, U.S. dollars.

Other guides