CastScience

Beaver Island: St. James Harbor and the Garden Island south shore

This Beaver Island area covers St. James Harbor and the Garden Island south shore 1.5 miles north, in about 3 to 25 ft. The U.S. Coast Pilot describes a shoal across the harbor and a gravel and boulder bank east of Luney Point. Winds from east to south cross about 25 to 42 km, giving about 3.5 to 4 ft at 20 mph.

The Great Lakes Aquatic Habitat Framework records spawning on gravel at Garden Island in June and at a Beaver Harbor site, read as St. James Harbor (an assumption), in late June. A 2013 In-Fisherman summary of tracked fish gives about 5 ft before the spawn, 5.5 ft during it and 13 ft after. St. James Township Boat Launch is about 0.9 mi away; mainland launches are crossings of 23 mi or more. Within one-half mile of Beaver and Garden islands smallmouth may be kept only from July 1 (Michigan fisheries order, as of October 2, 2026).

Sources: NOAA U.S. Coast Pilot 6, chapter 11, edition of 18 Oct 2026, paragraphs 150, 155-159: Garden Island, Beaver Island, St. James Harbor; Great Lakes Aquatic Habitat Framework, spawning and nursery sites: Beaver Island, 'Heaver Harbor' and Garden Island (records 3207-3209); Kaemingk, Great Lakes Smallmouth (In-Fisherman, 2013-05-31): summary of the Beaver Archipelago telemetry study. Written from the area's records and data, checked 2026-11-16.

WaterMichigan
Depth3-25 ft
BottomGravel at the spawning sites (Great Lakes Aquatic Habitat Framework, GLAHF 3208, 3209); a gravel and boulder bank covered 14 ft 2 mi east of Luney Point (Coast Pilot 6 para. 159)
CurrentNo
River plumeNo
Well-known spotNo
Position45.750, -85.495 (approximate center)

Beaver Archipelago studies since the 1970s: smallmouth now the dominant nearshore fish; tracked fish at about 5 ft before the spawn, 5.5 ft at spawning and 13 ft after it; spawning in late June in St. James Harbor (GLAHF)

Waves by wind direction and speed

Shore Protection Manual (SPM) shallow-water wave formulas at the area's wave depth for each direction (3.7-47.33 m), over-water wind, fetch from the lake outline. Hmax = 1.86 x Hs, the largest wave in about an hour. Slanting fetch: each Hs is the largest among the directions within 45 deg of the wind, with that direction's fetch, depth and period; the fetch shown is the wind direction's. Hs includes the lake's wave safety factor of 1.1. Depths are below low water datum, plus the lake level over the last 30 days (0.30 m). Science: waves

Wind fromFetch10 mph15 mph20 mph25 mph
N6.2 km0.9 ft / 1.7 ft1.6 ft / 2.9 ft2.2 ft / 4.1 ft2.9 ft / 5.3 ft
NE14.3 km1.3 ft / 2.4 ft2.3 ft / 4.2 ft3.2 ft / 6.0 ft4.2 ft / 7.9 ft
E31.9 km1.4 ft / 2.6 ft2.6 ft / 4.8 ft3.8 ft / 7.0 ft5.0 ft / 9.3 ft
SE39.8 km1.4 ft / 2.6 ft2.5 ft / 4.7 ft3.7 ft / 6.9 ft4.9 ft / 9.2 ft
S25.1 km1.4 ft / 2.5 ft2.5 ft / 4.7 ft3.7 ft / 6.8 ft4.9 ft / 9.1 ft
SW1.2 km1.2 ft / 2.2 ft2.0 ft / 3.8 ft3.0 ft / 5.5 ft3.9 ft / 7.3 ft
W1.9 km0.7 ft / 1.4 ft1.3 ft / 2.3 ft1.8 ft / 3.3 ft2.3 ft / 4.3 ft
NW8.9 km0.8 ft / 1.4 ft1.3 ft / 2.4 ft1.9 ft / 3.5 ft2.4 ft / 4.5 ft

Each cell: significant wave height / largest wave in about an hour. Above 2 ft: caution.

Wave model details

Wave heights are model estimates from forecast wind, not measurements, with a 1.10 safety factor. Actual waves were higher than the estimate in about 1 hour in 22 offshore and 1 in 13 near shore.

Check the marine forecast and the water at the launch; the decision to go out is yours. Full text

Boat ride from each launch

LaunchBoat ride
Manistique River Mouth Boat Launch (Michigan)39.2 mi
St. James Township Boat Launch (Michigan)1.6 mi
Wilderness State Park Boat Launch (Michigan)28.7 mi
Mackinaw City Marina Boat Launch (Michigan)37.9 mi
Port of Cross Village Park Boat Launch (Michigan)23.1 mi
Harbor Springs Boat Launch (Ford Park) (Michigan)35.0 mi
Petoskey Marina Boat Launch (Michigan)36.6 mi
Nine Mile Point Boat Launch (Michigan)30.9 mi
South Point Boat Launch (Lakeshore Drive) (Michigan)31.7 mi
Northport Marina Boat Launch (Michigan)45.8 mi
Suttons Bay North Park Boat Launch (Michigan)55.0 mi
Leland Harbor Boat Launch (Michigan)52.6 mi
West Arm Boat Launch (Michigan DNR) (Michigan)59.5 mi
Bowers Harbor Boat Launch (Michigan DNR) (Michigan)62.0 mi
Elmwood Township Marina Boat Launch (Michigan)67.3 mi
Clinch Park Boat Launch (Michigan)68.5 mi
East Arm Boat Launch (Michigan DNR) (Michigan)66.4 mi
Bunker Hill Road Boat Launch (Michigan)68.3 mi
Elk Rapids Harbor Boat Launch (Michigan)58.8 mi
Boat ride:
Distance along a path over water from the launch to the area, avoiding water charted under 2 ft. It measures the distance; it is not a course to steer.
Evidence
  • Great Lakes Fishery Commission, The State of Lake Michigan in 2016 (Special Publication 2019-01): inshore fish community Tue, Jan 1 2019
    As many as 50,000 smallmouth bass are caught and released each year in Michigan's Grand Traverse Bay, and the condition of smallmouth in northern Lake Michigan is at an all-time high. Smallmouth abundance and growth continue to increase in Green Bay, Grand Traverse Bay and major harbors; smallmouth and other nearshore fish have benefited from round goby in their diets.
    Source
  • Wisconsin DNR, Smallmouth Bass in the Great Lakes (Fetzer, management meeting slides, 2017-10-18): Beaver Archipelago and Waugoshance Point net catch Wed, Oct 18 2017
    Smallmouth catch per net-night in the Beaver Archipelago about 3.0 (2009), 5.0 (2010), 1.5 (2011) and 0.9 (2012); at Waugoshance Point about 2.5 (2012).
    Source
  • Clapp, Galarowicz, Clevenger, Martin, Kaemingk and Wehrly, Carl Latta, Herb Lenon, and 60+ years of smallmouth bass research in northern Lake Michigan (Midwest Fish and Wildlife Conference, 2016-01-26, abstract) Tue, Jan 26 2016
    Waugoshance Point smallmouth were studied in 1953-1955; about 20 years later and 25 miles across the lake a Michigan DNR survey series began in the Beaver Island Archipelago that is among the longest-running data sets on smallmouth population dynamics in the Great Lakes. The early findings are compared with current Michigan DNR and Central Michigan University assessments.
    Source
  • Michigan DNR, DNR requests angler assistance in studying Lake Michigan smallmouth bass (news release, 2015-09-08) Tue, Sep 8 2015
    Central Michigan University and the Michigan DNR have tagged smallmouth in the Beaver Island Archipelago since 2005, at Waugoshance Point (Wilderness State Park) since 2009 and in parts of Grand Traverse Bay since 2014: more than 7,000 tagged and released. Tag returns gave information on movement and nesting habitat and showed smallmouth larger and more numerous than 20-30 years earlier; northern Lake Michigan smallmouth are among the fastest-growing of the species in North America.
    Source
  • Kaemingk, Great Lakes Smallmouth (In-Fisherman, 2013-05-31): summary of the Beaver Archipelago telemetry study Fri, May 31 2013
    Tracking of 16 smallmouth of 15-19 in at Beaver Island in 2007-2008: most stayed within the study site and two moved more than 40 miles; fish moved roughly half a mile a day, stayed close to shore in pre-spawn and spawn and moved offshore after the spawn. Typical depths: about 5 ft in pre-spawn, 5.5 ft during the spawn and 13 ft in post-spawn. Some post-spawn fish were near boulders, rock piles or drop-offs, but no habitat trend was found.
    Source
  • Kaemingk, Galarowicz, Clevenger, Clapp and Lenon (2012), Fish assemblage shifts and population dynamics of smallmouth bass in the Beaver Archipelago, northern Lake Michigan. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society 141:550-559 Sun, Jan 1 2012
    Comparison of 1969-1972, 1975, 1977 and 1984 with 2005-2008 in the Beaver Archipelago: the nearshore catch shifted from mostly brown bullhead to mostly smallmouth bass, now the dominant nearshore species. Smallmouth relative abundance, recruitment variability and mortality did not change significantly; condition (ages 5-7) and growth (ages 2-7) increased significantly. Recent mean total length about 13.6 in at age 4, 15.4 in at age 5 and 17.5 in at age 7, against about 12.8 in at age 7 historically.
    Source
  • Population Dynamics of Smallmouth Bass at Waugoshance Point, Northern Lake Michigan (American Fisheries Society 2011 annual meeting, poster P-193) Thu, Sep 1 2011
    A 2009-2010 survey repeated the methods of the 1953-1955 study. Compared with the 1950s, smallmouth at Waugoshance Point were longer, in better condition and longer at age; tagged fish moved to Waugoshance Point from the Beaver Archipelago, about 30 km (19 mi) away; round gobies appeared less dense at Waugoshance than at other nearshore Great Lakes sites.
  • Kaemingk, Galarowicz, Clevenger and Clapp (2011), Movement of smallmouth bass within the Beaver Island Archipelago, northern Lake Michigan. Journal of Great Lakes Research 37:625-631 Sat, Jan 1 2011
    16 smallmouth with ultrasonic transmitters tracked in the Beaver Archipelago in 2007-2008 through pre-spawn, spawn and post-spawn. Fish ranged farther during the spawn than before it; after the spawn both sexes moved offshore to deeper water, females farther than males; fish returned to the same sites from year to year more after the spawn than during it; two fish left the archipelago. Longest movement 59.0 km (36.7 mi); up to 658 m (0.41 mi) a day.
    Source
  • Kaemingk, Clem and Galarowicz (2011), The influence of habitat and environment on smallmouth bass nest sites and nest success in northern Lake Michigan. Journal of Great Lakes Research 37:380-385 Sat, Jan 1 2011
    Water temperature, bottom firmness and bottom roughness were measured on transects in four bays of northern Lake Michigan and compared with nest counts; temperature, effective fetch and storms were tested against nest success. Temperature explained most: transects with the most cumulative degree days above 15 C (59 F) during nesting held more nests and had higher nest success.
    Source
  • Seider (2003), smallmouth bass population in the Beaver Archipelago 1999-2002 (University of Georgia MS thesis) Fri, Aug 1 2003
    Population estimates for 1999-2002 compared with the 1970s-1980s: smallmouth abundance down 85-92% while growth and condition had increased; high adult survival and similar declines in non-game species pointed away from angler harvest; mortality of ages 3-5 up to 99%, which the author found consistent with double-crested cormorant predation. A 2005-2008 study found no significant change in relative abundance against the 1970s-1980s.
    Source
  • Great Lakes Aquatic Habitat Framework, spawning and nursery sites: Beaver Island, 'Heaver Harbor' and Garden Island (records 3207-3209)
    Smallmouth spawning recorded at Beaver Harbor (St. James) in late June on gravel, at Garden Island in June on gravel, and on Beaver Island on a sandy beach and dune shore.
    Source
  • NOAA U.S. Coast Pilot 6, chapter 11, edition of 18 Oct 2026, paragraphs 150, 155-159: Garden Island, Beaver Island, St. James Harbor
    Beaver Island: shoals extend 0.5-1 mile offshore except in Sandy Bay on the east side; reefs of 8-12 ft lie 1.5 miles east and 0.8 mile north-east of the island's north-east end, in the channel between the shoal banks of Beaver and Garden islands. St. James Harbor is protected on the east by Sucker Point; a shoal crosses the harbor from Sucker Point to St. James; shoals reach 0.4-1 mile from Luney Point; a gravel and boulder bank covered 14 ft lies 2 miles east of Luney Point. Garden Island, 1.5 miles north of Beaver Island, is surrounded by shoal water.
    Source