Charity Islands (Big Charity, Little Charity and their bank)
Big and Little Charity islands stand about 4 km apart on one shoal bank in outer Saginaw Bay, with sand and scattered boulders on the bank and more than 50% rock near both islands, 6 to 25 ft deep. Northeast winds cross about 150 km of open water and the table gives about 6.5 ft at 20 mph. The Caseville Municipal Harbor launch is a boat ride of about 10.8 mi, a crossing.
Both islands are smallmouth spawning sites in the undated Great Lakes Aquatic Habitat Framework. On June 7, 2024, in the spawn window, the Bassmaster College Series winners took four bedded smallmouth of about 4 lb near the islands. In August 2023 the Bass Pro Tour winner found a school of 4 to 5 lb smallmouth at Charity Island in 18 to 20 ft on a drop shot, inside the summer band of 10 to 25 ft. The islands are a closed National Wildlife Refuge; do not land.
Sources: GLAHF smallmouth spawning records 3133 (Charity Island) and 3134 (Little Charity Island), Goodyear et al. (1982) atlas as updated; GLAHF substrate polygons at the Charity Islands (Fielder 2002; Robbins 1986); NOAA U.S. Coast Pilot 6, chapter 10, paragraphs 98-99: Charity Islands and the Sand Point shoal bank; Bassmaster College Series at Saginaw Bay 2024; MLF Bass Pro Tour, Minn Kota Stage Seven at Saginaw Bay 2023. Written from the area's records and data, checked 2026-11-16.
Big and Little Charity islands, 4 km apart on one shoal bank, are smallmouth spawning sites (GLAHF). The 2023 Bass Pro Tour winner caught a school of 4-5 lb smallmouth here at 18-20 ft on a drop shot; the 2024 College Series winners took four bedded 4 lb fish near the islands in June. The islands are a National Wildlife Refuge closed to the public: do not land.
Waves by wind direction and speed
Shore Protection Manual (SPM) shallow-water wave formulas at the area's wave depth for each direction (4.28-69.01 m), over-water wind, fetch from the lake outline. Hmax = 1.86 x Hs, the largest wave in about an hour. Hs includes the lake's wave safety factor of 1.1. Depths are below low water datum, plus the lake level over the last 30 days (0.41 m). Science: waves
| Wind from | Fetch | 10 mph | 15 mph | 20 mph | 25 mph |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| N | 70.3 km | 1.6 ft / 3.0 ft | 3.2 ft / 5.9 ft | 4.8 ft / 8.9 ft | 6.4 ft / 11.9 ft |
| NE | 149.9 km | 1.9 ft / 3.5 ft | 4.1 ft / 7.7 ft | 6.5 ft / 12.2 ft | 8.9 ft / 16.6 ft |
| E | 84.0 km | 1.7 ft / 3.2 ft | 3.4 ft / 6.3 ft | 5.2 ft / 9.6 ft | 6.9 ft / 12.9 ft |
| SE | 15.1 km | 0.9 ft / 1.7 ft | 1.5 ft / 2.8 ft | 2.1 ft / 3.9 ft | 2.7 ft / 5.0 ft |
| S | 10.3 km | 0.8 ft / 1.4 ft | 1.3 ft / 2.4 ft | 1.8 ft / 3.3 ft | 2.3 ft / 4.2 ft |
| SW | 24.0 km | 1.1 ft / 2.0 ft | 1.8 ft / 3.4 ft | 2.5 ft / 4.7 ft | 3.2 ft / 6.0 ft |
| W | 20.4 km | 1.0 ft / 1.9 ft | 1.7 ft / 3.2 ft | 2.4 ft / 4.5 ft | 3.1 ft / 5.7 ft |
| NW | 15.5 km | 0.9 ft / 1.8 ft | 1.6 ft / 2.9 ft | 2.2 ft / 4.2 ft | 2.9 ft / 5.4 ft |
Each cell: significant wave height / largest wave in about an hour. Above 2 ft: caution.
Wave model details
Wave heights are model estimates, not measurements, with a 1.10 safety factor. Actual waves were higher than the estimate in about 1 hour in 13 with measured wind and 1 period in 5 with waves above 3.3 ft at forecast wind.
Check the marine forecast and the water at the launch; the decision to go out is yours. Full text
Guides: Charity Islands and the Port Austin reefs, Saginaw Bay: smallmouth bass guide; Wind direction and waves at each Saginaw Bay area
Boat ride from each launch
| Launch | Boat ride |
|---|---|
| Edward M. Golson Boat Launch (Michigan) | 38.3 mi |
| Independence Boat Launch (Bangor Township) (Michigan) | 38.2 mi |
| Saginaw River Mouth Boating Access Site (Michigan) | 35.2 mi |
| Smith Park Boat Launch (Michigan) | 36.9 mi |
| Finn Road Park Boat Launch (Michigan) | 33.8 mi |
| Pinconning County Park Boat Launch (Michigan) | 28.0 mi |
| Au Gres River launch (City of Au Gres) (Michigan) | 14.3 mi |
| East Tawas State Dock (Michigan) | 16.0 mi |
| Au Sable River Mouth Boat Launch (Michigan) | 25.6 mi |
| Caseville Municipal Harbor launch (Michigan) | 10.8 mi |
| Filion Road Boating Access Site (Michigan) | 14.0 mi |
| Bay Port Boating Access Site (Michigan) | 14.0 mi |
| Port Austin State Harbor launch (Michigan) | 22.2 mi |
| Grindstone City boating access (Michigan) | 27.6 mi |
- Boat ride:
- Distance along a path over water from the launch to the area, avoiding water charted under 2 ft. It measures the distance; it is not a course to steer.
- Michigan DNR Weekly Fishing Report, Tawas/Au Gres, 2026-07-01 Wed, Jul 1 2026Tawas and Au Gres: smallmouth anglers caught a few on rock piles in the Tawas area; anglers who went to Charity Island for bass did well on both largemouth and smallmouth.Source
- Bassmaster College Series at Saginaw Bay, June 6-7, 2024: second place (Anglers Channel) Sat, Jun 8 2024Wielgopolski and Jagdfeld (Adrian College), 19-4 on day 2 and 32-9 in total, ran about two hours in big waves "out there to the (Charity) Islands" on day 2, when the bay was opened again after a day confined to the Saginaw River. The day 2 big bass of the event was a 5-2 smallmouth (fourth place).Source
- Bassmaster College Series at Saginaw Bay 2024 Thu, Jun 6 2024Branden Burrill and Jack Simpson (Western Michigan University): Day 1: the bay closed by B.A.S.S. for wind, every team in the Saginaw River (about 16 lb). Day 2: four smallmouth of about 4 lb each, all off a bed marked in practice, "out (by the Charity Islands)" some 30 mi into the bay after a two-hour boat ride; a last-minute largemouth from the Saginaw River on the way back; Jig (Beast Coast O.W. Sniper Jig, green pumpkin) and drop shots; the day-2 kicker largemouth on the jig.Source
- MLF Bass Pro Tour, Minn Kota Stage Seven at Saginaw Bay 2023 Tue, Aug 1 2023Matt Becker: Charity Island: a short stretch found in the Knockout Round held one small school of 10-15 smallmouth, all 4-5 lb; the final day began near the ramp and moved out to Charity Island in the first period (22-11 that day), 18-20 ft; Drop shot (Yamamoto Shad Shape Worm, size 4 hook, 1/2 oz weight, 15 lb braid with 10 lb fluorocarbon leader).Source
- Michigan DNR Weekly Fishing Report, Tawas, 2022-05-25 Wed, May 25 2022Tawas: pike, largemouth and smallmouth bass at Gateway Park on the Tawas River on jigs, body baits and crawlers; smallmouth anglers caught fish along the shore, out near the point and south near the Charity Islands casting jigs and plastics.Source
- Gwizdz, Saginaw Bay Bass (Great Lakes Angler) Tue, Aug 25 2020When the lake fell and zebra mussels cleared the water (visibility to 20 ft), bass anglers found large schools of smallmouth on open-water structure, larger on average than the largemouth; GPS made shipwrecks and underwater structure easy to return to, and faster boats put the 20 mi boat ride to the Charity Islands within reach; five-fish smallmouth stringers pushed 25 lb. Local tournament anglers fish smallmouth on rock piles and open-water structure; largemouth fishing in the reeds returned with higher water.Source
- Michigan DNR Weekly Fishing Report, Au Gres, 2019-06-27 Thu, Jun 27 2019Au Gres: walleye limits in 30-45 ft and a few near the Charity Islands; good numbers of smallmouth bass were taken on tube jigs near the islands.Source
- Great Lakes Fishery Commission, The State of Lake Huron in 2010 (Special Publication 13-01) Tue, Jan 1 2013Most of the main basin of Lake Huron is too cold and unproductive for large numbers of centrarchids; smallmouth support sport fisheries in some regions, most notably the Les Cheneaux Islands, the St. Marys River, parts of the North Channel and eastern Georgian Bay, outer Saginaw Bay and the Harbor Beach area.Source
- GLAHF smallmouth spawning records 3133 (Charity Island) and 3134 (Little Charity Island), Goodyear et al. (1982) atlas as updated Charity Island (44.0333 N, 83.4333 W) and Little Charity Island (44.0000 N, 83.4667 W): smallmouth spawning "yes"; substrate sand, rock, gravel.Source
- GLAHF substrate polygons at the Charity Islands (Fielder 2002; Robbins 1986) Within 1.5 km of the GNIS Charity Island point: a polygon of more than 50% rock (Fielder 2002) and sand of 0.25-0.5 mm. Within 1.5 km of Little Charity Island: more than 50% rock (Fielder 2002), gravel or coarser (phi below 0) and sand (Robbins 1986).Source
- NOAA U.S. Coast Pilot 6, chapter 10, paragraphs 98-99: Charity Islands and the Sand Point shoal bank From Sand Point a shoal bank extends about 13 mi north-west; Little Charity Island and Charity Island stand on it about 7 and 8 mi north-west of Sand Point. Between the point and the islands the bottom is generally sandy with scattered boulders; 7 ft is available across the shoal but prevailing depths are less. From Charity Island the bank extends about 3.5 mi west and 4 mi north; numerous spots of 13-20 ft lie 3-5 mi north-east of the island. A lighted buoy 5.5 mi north-west of the island marks the bank's north-west end; a 17 ft spot lies 3.6 mi west-north-west of the island.Source
- Fish Michigan's Lake Huron, Saginaw Bay (bassmaster.com tips page; search extract) Summer smallmouth on deeper drop-offs, reefs and rock piles, fished with tubes and drop shot rigs; the biggest from rocky, current-swept bottom around the Charity Islands; gobies have added weight, with an average of 2-3 lb and some of 6 lb or more.Source